OpenSSH/Cookbook/Proxies and Jump Hosts
A proxy is an intermediary that forwards requests from clients to other servers. Performance improvement, load balancing, security or access control are some reasons proxies are used.
- 1 SOCKS Proxy
- 2 Port Forwarding Via a Single Intermediate Host
- 3 Jump Hosts -- Passing Through a Gateway or Two
- 3.1 Passing Through One or More Gateways Using ProxyJump
- 3.2 Old Methods of Passing Through Jump Hosts
- 4 SSH Over Tor
- 5 Passing Through a Gateway with an Ad Hoc VPN
It is possible to connect via an intermediate machine using a SOCKS proxy. SOCKS4 and SOCKS5 proxies are currently supported by OpenSSH. SOCKS5 allows transparent traversal of a firewall or other barrier by an application and can use strong authentication with help of GSS-API. Dynamic application-level port forwarding allows the outgoing port to be allocated on the fly thus creating a proxy at the TCP session level.
Here the web browser can connect to the SOCKS proxy on port 3555 on the local host:
$ ssh -D 3555 server.example.org
Using ssh(1) as a SOCKS5 proxy, or in any other capacity where forwarding is used, you can specify multiple ports in one action:
$ ssh -D 80 -D 8080 -f -C -q -N email@example.com
You'll also want the DNS requests to go via your proxy. So, for example, changing about:config needs network.proxy.socks_remote_dns set to true But in Chromium, you'll need to launch the browser while adding two run-time options --proxy-server and --host-resolver-rules to point to the proxy and tell the browser not to send any DNS requests over the open network.
It will be similar for other programs that support SOCKS proxies.
You can tunnel Samba over ssh(1), too.
SOCKS Proxy Via a Single Intermediate Host
If you want to open a SOCKS proxy via an intermediate host, it is possible:
$ ssh -D 3555 -J firstname.lastname@example.org email@example.com
On older clients, an extra step is needed.
$ ssh -L 8001:localhost:8002 firstname.lastname@example.org -t ssh -D 8002 email@example.com
In the second example, the client will see a SOCKS proxy on port 8001 on the local host, which is actually a connection to machine1 and the traffic will ultimately enter and leave the net through machine2. Port 8001 on the local host connects to port 8002 on machine1 which is a SOCKS proxy to machine2. The port numbers can be chosen to be whatever is needed, but forwarding privileged ports still requires root privileges.
Port Forwarding Via a Single Intermediate Host
Tunneling, also called port forwarding, is when a port on one machine mapped to a connection to a port on another machine. In that way remote services can be accessed as if they were local. Or in the case of reverse port forwarding, vice verse. Forwarding can be done directly from one machine to another or via a machine in the middle.
Below we are setting up a tunnel from the localhost to machine2, which is behind a firewall, machine1. The tunnel will be via machine1 which is publicly accessible and also has access to machine2.
$ ssh -L 2222:machine2.example.org:22 machine1.example.org
Next connecting to the tunnel will actually connect to the second host, machine2.
$ ssh -p 2222 remoteuser@localhost
It is possible to use all the options in this way, such as -X for X11 forwarding. Here is an example of running rsync(1) between the two hosts using machine1 as an intermediary with the above setup.
$ rsync -av -e "ssh -p 2222" /path/to/some/dir/ localhost:/path/to/some/dir/
Jump Hosts -- Passing Through a Gateway or Two
It is possible to connect to another host via one or more intermediaries so that the client can act as if the connection were direct.
The main method is to use an SSH connection to forward the SSH protocol through one or more jump hosts, using the ProxyJump directive, to an SSH server running on the target destination host. This is the most secure method because encryption is end-to-end. In addition to whatever other encryption goes on, the end points of the chain encrypt and decrypt each other's traffic. So the traffic passing through the intermediate hosts is always encrypted. But this method cannot be used if the intermediate hosts deny port forwarding.
Using the ProxyCommand option to invoke Netcat as the last in the chain is a variation of this for very old clients. The SSH protocol is forwarded by
nc instead of
ssh. Attention must also be paid to whether or not the username changes from host to host in the chain of SSH connections. The outdated netcat method does not allow a change of username. Other methods do.
When port forwarding is available the easiest way is to use ProxyJump in the configuration file or -J as a run-time parameter. An example of -J usage is:
$ ssh -J firewall.example.org:22 server2.example.org
The ProxyJump directive (-J) is so useful it has an entire sub-section below.
In older versions -J is not available. In this case the safest and most straightforward way is to use ssh(1)'s stdio forwarding (-W) mode to "bounce" the connection through an intermediate host.
$ ssh -o ProxyCommand="ssh -W %h:%p firewall.example.org" server2.example.org
This approach supports port-forwarding without further tricks.
Even older clients don't support the -W option. In this case
ssh -tt may be used. This forces TTY allocation and passes the SSH traffic as though typed, though this is less secure. To connect to server2 via firewall as the jump host:
$ ssh -tt firewall.example.com ssh -tt server2.example.org
That example opens an SSH session to the remote machine. You can also pass commands. For example, to reattach to a remote screen session using screen you can do the following:
$ ssh -tt firewall.example.com ssh -tt server2.example.org screen -dR
The chain can be arbitrarily long and is not limited to just two hosts. The disadvantage of this approach over stdio-forwarding at the network layer with -W or -J is that your session, any forwarded agent, X11 server, and sockets are exposed to the intermediate hosts.
Passing Through One or More Gateways Using ProxyJump
Host server2 HostName 192.168.5.38 ProxyJump firstname.lastname@example.org:22 User fred
Multiple jump hosts can be specified as a comma-separated list. The hosts will be visited in the order listed.
Host server3 HostName 192.168.5.38 ProxyJump email@example.com:22,firstname.lastname@example.org:2222 User fred
It also has the shortcut of -J when using it as a run-time parameter.
$ ssh -J email@example.com:22 firstname.lastname@example.org
Multiple jump hosts can be chained in the same way.
$ ssh -J email@example.com:22,firstname.lastname@example.org:2222 email@example.com
It is not possible to use both the ProxyJump and ProxyCommand directives in the same host configuration. The first one found is used and then the other blocked.
Transiting a Jump Host Which Has Multiple RDomains / Routing Tables
When passing through a jump host which has its relevant interfaces each on a different rdomain(4), it will be necessary to manipulate the routing tables manually. Specificially that means going back to an older method of transit which relies on netcat and uses ProxyCommand instead of ProxyJump so that route(8) can be added in the middle. Here is an example doing so using only run time parameters to pass through to rdomain 1:
$ ssh -o ProxyCommand="ssh firstname.lastname@example.org route -T 1 exec nc %h %p" email@example.com
That configuration can be made persistent by adding it to the client configuration file, ssh_config(5):
Host jump jumphost.example.org HostName jumphost.example.org User user1 IdentitiesOnly yes IdentityFile ~/.ssh/jump_key Host server server.example.com HostName 10.100.200.44 User fred IdentitiesOnly yes IdentityFile ~/.ssh/inside_key ProxyCommand ssh jump route -T 1 exec nc %h %p
With those settings, it is then possible to connect to the host on the LAN via the jump host simply with the line
ssh server and all the settings will be taken into use.
Otherwise, the recommended way would have been to use ProxyJump. For more on using the older ProxyCommand directive see the section below, ProxyCommand with Netcat.
Conditional Use of Jump Hosts
It is possible to use Match exec to select for difficult patterns or otherwise make complex decisions, such as which network the client is connecting from or the network connectivity of the available network(s). Below is an example of how to automatically use ProxyJump to connect via an intermediate host on occasions when there is no local IPv6 connectivity when connecting to a remote machine which has only IPv6 .
Match host ipv6only.example.org User fred Match host ipv6only.example.org !exec "route -n get -inet6 %h" ProxyJump dualstack.example.org
With those settings, connections to the machine ipv6only.example.org will go via a jump host only if it is not directly accessible via IPv6.
On GNU/Linux systems that capability would be more complicated.
Match host ipv6only.example.org User fred Match host ipv6only.example.org !exec "/sbin/ip route get $(host -t AAAA %h | sed 's/^.* //')" ProxyJump dualstack.example.org
The scripts are invoked using the shell named in the $SHELL environment variable. Remember that configuration directives are applied according to the first one to match. So specific rules go near the top and more general ones go at the end.
Old Methods of Passing Through Jump Hosts
In OpenSSH version 7.2 and earlier, passing through one or more gateways is more complex and requires use of stdio forwarding or, prior to 5.4, use of the netcat(1) utility.
Passing Through a Gateway Using stdio Forwarding (Netcat Mode)
Between OpenSSH 5.4 and 7.2 inclusive, a 'netcat mode' can connect stdio on the client to a single port forwarded on the server. This can also be used to connect using ssh(1), but it needs the ProxyCommand option either as a run time parameter or as part of ~/.ssh/config. However, it no longer needs netcat(1) to be installed on the intermediary machine(s). Here is an example of using it in a run time parameter.
$ ssh -o ProxyCommand="ssh -W %h:%p jumphost.example.org" server.example.org
In that example, authentication will happen twice, first on the jump host and then on the final host where it will bring up a shell.
The syntax is the same if the gateway is identified in the configuration file. ssh(1) expands the full name of the gateway and the destination from the configuration file. The following allows the destination host to be reached by entering
ssh server in the terminal.
Host server Hostname server.example.org ProxyCommand ssh jumphost.example.org -W %h:%p
The same can be done for SFTP. Here the destination SFTP server can be reached by entering
sftp sftpserver and the configuration file takes care of the rest. If there is a mix up with the final host key, then it is necessary to add in HostKeyAlias to explicitly name which key will be used to identify the destination system.
Host sftpserver HostName sftpserver.example.org HostKeyAlias sftpserver.example.org ProxyCommand ssh jumphost.example.org -W %h:%p
It is possible to add the key for the gateway to the ssh-agent which you have running or else specify it in the configuration file. The option User refers to the user name on the destination. If the user is the same on both the destination and the originating machine, then it does not need to be used. If the user name is different on the gateway, then the -l option can be used in the ProxyCommand option. Here, the user 'fred' on the local machine, logs into the gateway as 'fred2' and into the destination server as 'fred3'.
Host server HostName server.example.org User fred3 ProxyCommand ssh -l fred2 -i /home/fred/.ssh/rsa_key jumphost.example.org -W %h:%p
If both the gateway and destination are using keys, then the option IdentityFile in the config is used to point to the gateway's private key and the option IdentityFile specified on the commandline points at the destination's private key.
Host jump HostName server.example.org IdentityFile /home/fred/.ssh/rsa_key_2 ProxyCommand ssh -i /home/fred/.ssh/rsa_key jumphost.example.org -W %h:%p
The old way prior to OpenSSH 5.4 used netcat, nc(1).
Host server Hostname server.example.org ProxyCommand ssh jumphost.example.org nc %h %p
But that should not be used anymore and the netcat mode, provided by -W, should be used instead. The new way does not require netcat at all on any of the machines.
Recursively Chaining Gateways Using stdio Forwarding
The easy way to do this is with ProxyJump which is available starting with OpenSSH 7.3 mentioned above. For older versions, if the route always has the same hosts in the same order, then a straightforward chain can be put in the configuration file. Here three hosts are chained with the destination being given the shortcut machine3.
Host machine1 Hostname server.example.org User fred IdentityFile /home/fred/.ssh/machine1_e25519 Port 2222 Host machine2 Hostname 192.168.15.21 User fred IdentityFile /home/fred/.ssh/machine2_e25519 Port 2222 ProxyCommand ssh -W %h:%p machine1 Host machine3 Hostname 10.42.0.144 User fred IdentityFile /home/fred/.ssh/machine3_e25519 Port 2222 ProxyCommand ssh -W %h:%p machine2
Thus any machine in the chain can be reached with a single line. For example, the final machine can be reached with
ssh machine3 and worked with as normal. This includes port forwarding and any other capabilities.
Only hostname and, for second and subsequent hosts, ProxyCommand are needed for each Host directive. If keys are not used, then IdentityFile is not needed. If the user is the same for all hosts, the that can be skipped. And if the port is the default, then Port can be skipped. If using many keys in the agent at the same time and the error "too many authentication" pops up on the client end, it might be necessary to add IdentitiesOnly yes to each host's configuration.
Recursively Chaining an Arbitrary Number of Hosts
Again, the easy way to do this is with ProxyJump should be used when available, which is starting with OpenSSH 7.3. For older versions, it is possible to make the configuration more abstract and allow passing through an arbitrary number of gateways. You can set the user name with -l thanks to the token, but that user name will be used for all host that you connect to or through.
Host */* ProxyCommand ssh %r@$(dirname %h) -W $(basename %h):%p
In this way hosts are separated with a slash (/) and can be arbitrary in number.
$ ssh host1/host2/host3/host4
The following configuration uses sed(1) to allow different port numbers and user names using the plus sign (+) as the delimiter for hosts, a colon (:) for ports, and an percentage sign (%) for user names. The basic structure is
ssh -W $() $() and where %h is substituted for the target host name.
Host *+* ProxyCommand ssh -W $(echo %h | sed 's/^.*+//;s/^\([^:]*$\)/\1:22/') $(echo %h | sed 's/+[^+]*$//;s/\([^+%%]*\)%%\([^+]*\)$/\2 -l \1/;s/:\([^:+]*\)$/ -p \1/')
The port can be left off for the default of 22 or delimited with a colon (:) for non-standard values.
$ ssh host1+host2:2022+host3:2224
As-is, the colons confound sftp(1), so the above configuration will only work with it using standard ports. If sftp(1) is needed on non-standard ports then another delimiter, such as an underscore (_), can be configured.
Any user name except the final one can be specified for a given host using the designated delimiter, in the above it is a percentage sign (%). The destination host's user name is specified with -l and all others can be joined to their corresponding host name with the delimiter.
$ ssh -l user3 user1%host1+user2%host2+host3
If user names are specified, depending on the delimiter, ssh(1) can be unable to match the final host to an IP number and the key fingerprint in known_hosts. In such cases, it will ask for verification each time the connection is established, but this should not be a problem if either the equal sign (=) or percentage sign (%) is used.
If keys are to be used then load them into an agent, then the client figures them out automatically if agent forwarding with the -A option is used. However, agent forwarding is not needed if the ProxyJump option (-J) is available. It is considered by many to actually be a security flaw and a general misfeature. So use the ProxyJump option instead if it is available. Also, because the default for MaxAuthTries on the server is 6, using keys normally in an agent will limit the number of keys or hops to 6, with server-side logging getting triggered after half that.
ProxyCommand with Netcat
Another way, which was needed for OpenSSH 5.3 and older, is to use the ProxyCommand configuration directive and netcat. The utility nc(1) is for reading and writing network connections directly. It can be used to pass connections onward to a second machine. In this case, login is the final destination reached via the intermediary jumphost.
$ ssh -o 'ProxyCommand ssh %h nc login.example.edu 22' \ -o 'HostKeyAlias=login.example.edu' \ jumphost.example.org
Keys and different login names can also be used. Using ProxyCommand, ssh(1) will first connect to jumphost and then from there to login.example.edu. The HostKeyAlias directive is needed to look up the right key for login.example.edu, without it the key for jumphost will be tried and that will, of course, fail unless both have the same keys. The account user2 exists on jumphost.
$ ssh -o 'ProxyCommand ssh -i key-rsa -l user2 %h nc login.example.edu 22' \ -o 'HostKeyAlias=login.example.edu' \ jumphost.example.org
It's also possible to make this arrangement more permanent and reduce typing by editing ssh_config Here a connection is made to host2 via host1:
Host host2.example.org ProxyCommand ssh firstname.lastname@example.org nc %h %p
Here a connection is made to server2 via server1 using the shortcut name 'jump'.
Host jump ProxyCommand ssh %h nc server2.example.org 22 HostKeyAlias server2.example.org Hostname server1.example.org User fred
It can be made more general:
Host gateway.example.org ProxyCommand none Host *.example.org my-private-host ProxyCommand ssh email@example.com nc %h %p
The same can be done with sftp(1) by passing parameters on to ssh(1). Here is a simple example with sftp(1) where machine1 is the jump host to connect to machine2. The user name is the same for both hosts.
$ sftp -o 'ProxyCommand=ssh %h nc machine2.example.edu 22' \ -o 'HostKeyAlias=machine2.example.edu' \ firstname.lastname@example.org
Here is a more complex example using a key for server1 but regular password-based login for the SFTP server.
$ sftp -o 'ProxyCommand ssh -i /Volumes/Home/fred/.ssh/server1_rsa \ -l user2 server1.example.edu nc sftp.example.edu 22' \ -o 'HostKeyAlias=sftp.example.edu' sftp.example.edu
If the user accounts names are different on the two machines, that works, too. Here, 'user2' is the account on the second machine which is the final target. The user 'fred' is the account on the intermediary or jump host.
$ ssh -l user2 \ -o 'ProxyCommand ssh -l fred %h nc machine2.example.org 22' \ -o 'HostKeyAlias machine2.example.org' \ machine1.example.org
SSH Over Tor
Tunneling SSH Over Tor with Netcat
|These instructions use the port number 9050 which corresponds to the Tor system daemon. For Tor Browser, substitute with port 9150 and have Tor Browser open.|
Besides using ssh(1) as a SOCKS proxy, it is possible to tunnel the SSH protocol itself over a SOCKS proxy such as Tor. Tor is anonymity software and a corresponding network that uses relay hosts to conceal a user's location and network activity. Its architecture is intended to prevent surveillance and traffic analysis. Tor can be used in cases where it is important to conceal the point of origin of the SSH client. It can also be used to connect to onion services. Unfortunately, connecting through Tor often comes at the expense of noticeable latency.
On the end point that the client sees, Tor is a regular SOCKS5 proxy and can be used like any other SOCKS5 proxy. So this is tunneling SSH over a SOCKS proxy. The easiest way to do this is with the
torsocks utility if available, simply by preceding a SSH command with it:
$ torsocks ssh email@example.com
However, this can also be accomplished by using netcat:
$ ssh -o ProxyCommand="nc -X 5 -x localhost:9050 %h %p" firstname.lastname@example.org
When attempting a connection like this, it is very important that it does not leak information. In particular, the DNS lookup should occur over Tor and not be done by the client itself. Make sure that if VerifyHostKeyDNS is used that it be set to 'no'. The default is 'no' but check to be sure. It can be passed as a run-time argument to remove any doubt or uncertainty.
$ ssh -o VerifyHostKeyDNS=no -o ProxyCommand="nc -X 5 -x localhost:9050 %h %p" server.example.org
Using the netcat-openbsd nc(1) package, this seems not to leak any DNS information. Other netcat packages might or might not be the same. It's also not clear if there are other ways in which this method might leak information. YMMV.
Since these methods proxy through Tor, all of them will also enable connecting to onion services. You can configure SSH to automatically connect to these through Tor, without affecting other types of connections. An entry similar to the following can be added to ssh_config or ~/.ssh/config:
Host *.onion VerifyHostKeyDNS no ProxyCommand nc -x localhost:9050 -X 5 %h %p
You can further add CanonicalizeHostname yes before any Host declarations so that if you give onion services a nickname, SSH will apply this configuration after determining the hostname is a .onion address.
Providing SSH as an Onion Service
SSH can be served from an .onion address to provide anonymity and privacy for the client and, to a certain extent, the server. Neither will know where the other is located, though a lot of additional precautions must be taken to come close to anonymizing the server itself and at least some level of trusting the users will still be necessary.
The first step in making SSH available over Tor is to set up sshd_config(5) so that the SSH service listens on the localhost address and only on the localhost address.
Multiple ListenAddress directives can be used if multiple ports are to be made available. However, any ListenAddress directives provided should bind only to addresses in the 127.0.0.0/8 network or the IPv6 equivalent. Listening to any WAN or LAN address would defeat Tor's anonymity by allowing the SSH server to be identified from its public keys.
The next step in serving SSH over Tor is to set up a Tor client with a hidden service forwarded to the local SSH server. Follow the instructions for installing a Tor client given at the Tor Project web site, but skip the part about the web server if it is not needed. Add the appropriate HiddenServicePort directive to match the address and that sshd(8) is using.
HiddenServicePort 22 127.0.0.1:22
If necessary, add additional directives for additional ports. In newer versions of Tor, a 56-character version 3 onion address can be made by adding
HiddenServiceVersion 3 to the Tor configuration in versions that support it.
Be sure that HiddenServiceDir points to a location appropriate for your system. The onion address of the new SSH service will then be in the file hostname inside the directory indicated by the HiddenServiceDir directive and will be accessible regardless of where it is on the net or how many layers of NAT have it buried. To use the SSH service and verify that it is actually available over Tor, see the preceding section on using the SSH client over Tor with Netcat.
Just making it available over Tor is not enough alone to anonymize the server. However, one of the other advantages of this method is NAT punching. If the SSH service is behind several layers of NAT, then providing it as an Onion service allows passing through those layers seamlessly without configuring each router at each layer. This eliminates the need for a reverse tunnel to an external server and works through an arbitrary number of layers of NAT such as are now found with mobile phone modems.
Passing Through a Gateway with an Ad Hoc VPN
Two subnets can be connected over SSH by configuring the network routing on the end points to use the tunnel. The result is a VPN. A drawback is that root access is needed on both hosts, or at least sudo(8) access to ifconfig(8) and route(8). A related more limited and more archaic approach, not presented here but which does not require root at the remote end, would be to use
ssh to establish connectivity and then establish a network using PPP and
Note that there are very few instances where use of a VPN is legitimately called for, not because VPNs are illegal (quite the opposite, indeed data protection laws in many countries make them absolutely compulsory to protect content in transit) but simply because OpenSSH is usually flexible enough to complete most routine sysadmin and operational tasks using normal SSH methods as and when required. This SSH ad-hoc VPN method is therefore needed only very rarely.
Take this example with two networks. One network has the address range 10.0.50.1 through 10.0.50.254. The other has the address range 172.16.99.1 through 172.16.99.254. Each has a machine, 10.0.50.1 and 172.16.99.1 respectively, that will function as a gateway. Local machine numbering starts with 3 because 2 will be used for the tunnel interfaces on each LAN.
+----10.0.50.1 172.16.99.1----+ + 10.0.50.2 ===== 172.16.99.2 + | | 10.0.50.3-----+ +---172.16.99.3 | | 10.0.50.4-----+ +---172.16.99.4 | | 10.0.50.5-----+ +---172.16.99.5 | | 10.0.50.etc---+ +---172.16.99.etc | | 10.0.50.254---+ +---172.16.99.254
First a tun device is created on each machine, a virtual network device for point-to-point IP tunneling. Then the tun interfaces on these two gateways are then connected by an SSH tunnel. Each tun interface is assigned an IP address.
The tunnel connects machines 10.0.50.1 and 172.16.99.1 to each other, and each are already connected to their own local area network (LAN). Here is a VPN with the client as 10.0.50.0/24, remote as 172.16.99.0/24. First, set on the client:
$ ssh -f -w 0:1 192.0.2.15 true $ ifconfig tun0 10.1.1.1 10.1.1.2 netmask 255.255.255.252 $ route add 172.16.99.0/24 10.1.1.2
On the server:
$ ifconfig tun1 10.1.1.2 10.1.1.1 netmask 255.255.255.252 $ route add 10.0.50.0/24 10.1.1.1
- "SOCKS Protocol version 5". IETF. http://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc1928. Retrieved 2011-02-17.
- "Configuring a SOCKS proxy server in Chrome". The Chromium Projects. https://www.chromium.org/developers/design-documents/network-stack/socks-proxy. Retrieved 2016-12-10.
- "OpenSSH 7.3 Release Notes". OpenSSH. 2016-08-01. http://www.openssh.com/txt/release-7.3. Retrieved 2016-08-01.
- Peter Hessler (2018-12-04). "phessler@". Mastodon. https://bsd.network/@phessler/101182487005125208. Retrieved 2018-12-05.
- Williams, Miklos (2017-07-13). "Tunneling an SSH connection only when necessary using Match". https://mike.place/2017/ssh-match/. Retrieved 2018-12-05.
- "OpenSSH 5.4 Release Notes". OpenSSH. 2010-04-07. http://www.openssh.com/txt/release-5.4. Retrieved 2013-04-19.
- Josh Hoblitt (2011-09-03). "Recursively chaining SSH ProxyCommand". [Read This Fine Material] from Joshua Hoblitt. https://joshua.hoblitt.com/rtfm/2011/09/recursively_chaining_ssh_proxycommand/. Retrieved 2014-02-14.
- Mike Hommey (2016-02-08). "SSH through jump hosts, revisited". glandium. https://glandium.org/blog/?p=3631. Retrieved 2016-02-09.
- "SSH Over Tor". The Tor Project. 2012-08-28. https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/wiki/doc/TorifyHOWTO/ssh. Retrieved 2013-05-04.
- "Configuring Hidden Services for Tor". The Tor Project, Inc. https://www.torproject.org/docs/tor-hidden-service#two. Retrieved 2016-12-09.
- "Tor Rendezvous Specification - Version 3". The Tor Project, Inc.. 2015-05-26. https://gitweb.torproject.org/torspec.git/tree/rend-spec-v3.txt. Retrieved 2018-12-14.
- Jeremy Impson (2008-09-16). "pppsshslirp: create a PPP session through SSH to a remote machine to which you don't have root". http://jdimpson.livejournal.com/3330.html. Retrieved 2016-12-10.