Public-Private Partnership Policy Casebook/Eagle
Eagle P3 Denver, CO:
The Eagle P3 project is a Public-Private Partnership between the Regional Transportation District of Denver, CO, and Denver Transit Partners, a private consortium made up of more than eight different private construction, consulting, engineering, and financial companies. Denver Transit Partners has secured a $2.2 billion contract to design, build, finance, operate, and maintain (DBFOM) three new commuter rail lines, spanning more than 36 miles, in the Denver metro area. It is the first public transit DBFOM P3 project undertaken in the United States.
The project is currently under construction with the East Line, connecting downtown Denver with Denver International Airport (23 miles east of the city), expected to open in January 2016. Two other lines include the Northwest Electrified Segment which will run from Denver to the north metro suburb of Westminster, CO,and the Gold Line which will run west of the city to the suburb of Arvada, CO (toward the city of Golden, CO). The long term vision for Denver's Metro Public Transit system (called FasTracks) includes the Northwest Line reaching as far as Longmont, CO (38 miles north of Denver) via the college town of Boulder, CO, and southern rail lines reaching Littleton, Co and Centennial, CO to the south, in all connecting 122 miles of rail transit into Downtown Denver. The central hub of the commuter rail system will be Downtown Denver's Union Station, which is undergoing a $500 million redevelopment as part of the project.
Annotated List of Actors
- Regional Transportation District of Denver, Colorado (RTD): This is the principle public transportation authority serving the Denver Metropolitan Area providing bus and light rail service to eight counties. FasTracks is the name of the new multi-billion dollar transit system expansion project that the agency is currently undertaking . The Eagle P3 is a major component of RTD's FasTracks Project and RTD is the lead Sponsor agency responsible for the Public Private Partnerships associated with the Project. It is also a revenue-raising authority, generating project funds through revenue bonds and a voter-approved added sales and use tax on goods and services within the District's eight county region.
- Denver Transit Partners (DTP) – Selected as the winning bid in the Eagle P3 Project, the Concessionaire was created as a partnership between Fluor Enterprises, Inc. (a unit of Fluor Corp.); Denver Rail (Eagle) Holdings, Inc. (a unit of John Laing PLC) and Uberior Infrastructure Investments(No 4)USA LLC.(a unit of Lloyds Banking Group.) Other team members include: Balfour Beatty Rail Inc., Alternative Concepts, Inc., Ames Construction, Systra Consulting, Hyundai-Rotem USA and HDR Global Design Consultants. 
- Federal Transit Administration (FTA) - The Federal Government, through the FTA, is providing about $1.03 billion of capital funds to the project through the Public-Private Partnership Pilot Program (Penta-P) to demonstrate the advantages of using a P3 for transit projects. The Eagle P3 project is the first of three transit projects designated through the FTA Penta-P initiative and will serve as a model for future P3 public transit across the country. The funding is coming primarily from FTA's Section 5309 New Starts Capital Program.
- U.S.DOT - In addition to New Starts funding from FTA, the Dept. of Transportation is also supporting the project with $280 million in direct TIFIA loans. The Transportation Infrastructure Finance and Innovation Act program began in 1998 and has provided billions of dollars in loans, loan guarantees, and credit assistance to help secure private financing interest in major surface transportation infrastructure projects across the U.S.
DTP's Project Contractor Entities
- Denver Transit Systems (DTS) - Design-Build Contractor, (Fluor and Balfour Beatty Rail, Inc.)
- Denver Transit Constructors (DTC) - Design-Build Subcontractor Group, (Flour, Balfour Beatty Rail Inc, and Ames Construction)
- Hyundai-Rotem USA - Rolling Stock Provider (Locomotives and Rail Cars)
- Denver Transit Operators (DTO) - Operations and Maintenance Contractor (Flour, Balfour Beatty Rail Inc, and ACI)
Timeline of Events
- April 2004 - RTD develps FasTracks plan, a multi-billion dollar public transportation expansion plan which would add 122 miles of new commuter rail service, 18 miles of BRT service, 57 new total transit stations, and a total of 21,000 new parking spaces. The project is expected to cost $4.7 billion and open by 2017
- November 2004 - Denver Metro Area voters approve 0.4 percent sales tax increase to fund FasTracks.
- August 2007 - Federal Transit Administration (FTA) selects Eagle Project as part of the Public-Private Partnership Pilot Program (Penta-P). Penta-P program was established to demonstrate the advantages and disadvantages of P3s for certain new fixed-guideway capitol projects within the New Starts program.
- August 2008 - RTD issues Request for Qualifications (RFQ) for the Eagle P3 project. The Eagle project consists of the East Rail Line connecting downtown Denver with Denver International Airport, the Gold Line, Northwest Electrified Segment, a new fleet of electric commuter rail vehicles, and a maintenance facility for the new railcars. Three potential concessionaire teams respond to the RFQ, and all three are found to be qualified to continue the procurement process.
- September 2009 - Following a year of discussion with stakeholders and the potential concessionaire teams, RTD issues a Request for Proposal (RFP) to the teams.
- April 2010 – RTD receives final technical and financial proposals from concessionaire teams.
- June 15, 2010 - RTD Board of Directors votes unanimously to award the Eagle P3 contract to Denver Transit Partners (DTP)
- July 9, 2010 - Contract is signed
- August 12, 2010 – Financial closing. RTD simultaneously issues Notice to Proceed for Phase I of the project, allowing DTP to proceed with final design of the project, construction of the East Rail Line, the maintenance facility and the tracks from Denver Union Station (DUS) to the maintenance facility and the provision of all of the rolling stock required for the project.
- August 31, 2011 - FTA approves $1 Billion Federal Funding Grant Agreement for Eagle P3. New funding allows for RTD to issue NTP for Phase II of the project, which includes construction of the Gold Line and first segment of the Northwest Line.
- May 9, 2014 - Completion of Denver Union Station rehabilitation, the main terminal for the commuter lines.
- September 2014 - Commuter Rail Maintenance Facility turned over from construction contractors to Denver Transit Partners.
- January 2016 - The first new commuter rail line, the East Line to Denver International Airport is expected to open.
Timeline derived from RTD FasTracks website on Eagle P3 project 
Maps of Locations
Narrative of the Case
In early 2004, the Regional Transportation District of Denver, Colorado and its surrounding areas worked to develop a plan to tackle growing congestion issues in the region. The city had been ranked as the third most congested metro area in the country, and the lack of a comprehensive, high-quality public transportation network was cited as one of the top transportation issues in the area. In addition, according to the Denver Regional Council of Governments, the region is expected to add 900,000 more residents and 600,000 more jobs by the year 2025. With these extra people using the transportation network, VMT was expected to increase 64%, which was in turn expected to increase severe congestion by 89%.
After examining the situation, RTD published their FasTracks plan to significantly improve the public transportation system in the Denver region. FasTracks called for the construction of 122 miles of new commuter rail service, 18 miles of BRT service, 57 new total transit stations, and a total of 21,000 new park and ride spaces. RTD listed the three main goals of FasTracks as:
1. Additional Transportation Options
Additional transportation choices add to the region’s quality of life. Reduced reliance on a single mode of transportation by providing additional, convenient transit options gives individuals choices on how to travel and where to live, work and play. FasTracks provides over 119 miles of new rail transit, contributes to the construction of 18 miles of bus rapid transit and greatly enhances the bus network to support investments in rail, serve suburb-to-suburb trips, and provide local and regional service.
2. Increase use of Public Transit
Existing congestion during peak travel times of the day is frustrating for many drivers and is only expected to get worse as the region continues to grow. Providing viable transit options during the peak travel times will help provide relief for frustrated drivers. FasTracks is projected to increase the percentage of people taking transit during the peak hours from 11 to 22 percent in the region’s major transportation corridors where congestion is worst.
3. Meet Future Transportation Needs
The Denver metropolitan region is expected to grow from 2.46 million (2001) people to 3.39 million in 2025. This growth requires an enhanced transit system to help meet the future transportation needs of the region. FasTracks responds to this need and provides opportunities to focus development near transit to take advantage of the increased capacity and convenience of the enhanced system. 
Eagle P3 Project Overview 
The Eagle P3 project combines two of the planned commuter rail lines from FasTracks plus a segment of a third and a maintenance facility for new the new rolling stock into a single PPP concession contract. The three lines spread out from their terminal at Denver Union Station in downtown Denver, where they connect with RTD bus and light rail lines. The Eagle project will help to jump start the new commuter rail program, as the two other planned commuter rail lines will also use the same rolling stock and will be supported by the same maintenance facility.
The East Line is a 22.8 mile electrified commuter rail line that connects Denver Union Station to Denver International Airport. The line will also serve five additional stations in Denver's eastern suburbs, adding 3,529 park and ride spaces on opening day with an eventual expansion to 7,900. Construction on the East Line began in August, 2010 and the line is expected to open in January 2016.
The Gold Line will run 11.2 mile electrified commuter rail line from Denver Union Station to the nearby west suburb of Wheat Ridge, serving 7 stations along the route. This line will add 2,300 new park and ride spots on opening day with an eventual expansion to 2,890 spaces. Construction on the Gold Line began in 2011 as part of Phase II and is planned to open in summer 2016.
Northwest Electrified Segment
The Northwest Electrified Segment is the third and final new electrified commuter rail line being built as part of the Eagle project. The electrified segment will run 6.2 miles from Union Station to South Westminster, a suburb northwest of Denver. FasTracks has planned for the line to eventually be expanded 41 miles to Boulder and Longmont, but cost overruns and the economic downturn in 2009 required the RTD to postpone the full development of the Northwest Line until 2044 unless additional funding is found. The segment to Westminster is planned to open in March 2016
Commuter Rail Maintenance Facility and New Rolling Stock
As part of the contract to build the rail lines, Denver Transit Partners is also tasked with acquiring new rolling stock and building a $224 million maintenance facility to service the new railcars. DTP chose Hyundai-Rotem to build 50 electric multiple-unit (EMU) cars similar to the new Silverliner V recently delivered to Philadelphia. The cars will be built at Hyundai-Rotem's plant in South Philadelphia and meet Buy America requirements for 60% of components to be produced in the United States. RTD chose heavier commuter rail cars rather than to expand their existing light rail network because of federal regulations required due to the proximity of the new rail lines to existing freight lines. However, the EMU cars offer fast acceleration and higher capacity than the light-rail cars, which will make these cars more effective on the longer commuter lines.
Bidding/Procurement and Concession Agreement
The Eagle P3 Project is a 34 year DBFOM concession agreement (5 years design, build and finance + 29 years operations and maintenance) with construction payments and availability adjusted service payments to the concessionaire by RTD. The bidding process began in August 2008 with a Request for Qualifications through which three groups became pre-qualified to respond to the 2009 Request for Proposals competition. The RFQ was designed to gauge private interest, opportunities, project alignment, and feasibility of quickly completing a revenue-raising P3 portion of the FasTracks project. This portion was called the "Eagle Project" ("East And Gold Line Enterprise"), and was set to be completed in two phases between 2010 and 2016.
The three groups that were pre-qualified through the RFQ process included "Denver Transit Partners" -A joint-subsidiary formed between Fluor Enterprises Inc. (Texas, USA) and Macquarie Capital Group (Australia), "Mile-High Transit" - led by John Laing, PLC (UK), and "Mountain Air Transit" - led by Babcock & Brown (Australia). 
Through the RFQ feedback received, the RTD decided to issue the Request for Proposals in the form of performance-based standards instead of detailed design specifications. RTD relied on base industry standards for public transit, and on the Concessionaire incentive, as the Operator and Maintainer of the system, to construct a quality system. After the RFQ, RTD dumped more than 800 pages of design specifications from the RFP process. RTD created the Alternative Technical Concepts (ATC) Process to replace the traditional Value Engineering process (which is a U.S.DOT mandated process for determining the value of a design based on its function to cost ratio). The ATC process, approved by DOT, allowed the concessionaire to propose innovative, quality improving, and cost-efficient design changes that could be approved in the place of traditional design standards still remain in compliance. The RFP was issued in September 2009 with a due date of May 2010. The three pre-qualified partnerships were invited to participate and submit a proposal. The RFP set performance standards for the project based on Safety, Dependability, Cost Effectiveness, and User Considerations, but otherwise left the door open with a high degree of flexibility in the project design in the proposals. 
The Proposals were evaluated based on the Base Annual Service Payment (BASP) structure proposed (in terms of the lower BASP, the higher the score), the feasibility of the financial proposal, the price and quality of the rolling stock, how well the technical approach fits with the overall goals of the project including safety, systems integration, technical innovations, and O&M planning, the proposer's ability, creativity, and commitment level, and bonus points for value-added proposals above and beyond the base requirements of the project. 
The RFP process encouraged competitors to submit their cost-saving and innovative technical designs into the competition by providing compensation for the intellectual property rights of the proposal. This would allow the Eagle P3 project to use innovative ideas and aspects of different proposals to the project's overall advantage. First the RTD reduced the expense risk of submitting a proposal by offering a $20 million "insurance compensation" to teams that submit a proposal, in the event that RTD decided not to move forward with the project after receiving the bids. In addition, RTD offered a $2.5 million stipend to bidders who submitted proposals into the competition but did not receive the concession contract. This stipend was used in order to compensate the bidders for their design innovations and contributions to the project from their bids. 
Mile High Transit Partners dropped out of the competition in November 2009, citing internal problems between stakeholders, and the RFP was left with only two bidders. This has been cited as a serious lesson for the P3 project process which only pre-qualified three teams and ran the danger of only receiving one proposal bid for the project, setting itself up for a disadvantageous deal. Critics have reason to question the RTD in giving into proposer's project risk transfer issues, in their effort to keep the remaining two teams in the process and move forward with a competitive bid process. RTD counters that the two teams remaining were the only teams with the interest and strong qualifications necessary for a project of this size, and the competition remained very competitive despite the low number of bids.  Both DTP and Mountain Air Transit ended up submitting their proposals. The winning bid was announced in June 2010. The RTD board voted unanimously for the Denver Transit Partners team over Mountain Air Transit's Bid. The DTP bid came in with BASP savings of about $300 million, and a schedule that opened the system 11 months ahead of schedule. 
Mountain Air Transit was compensated $2.5 million for their bid from RTD's project funds, and in July 2010, RTD and DTP jointly decided to reduce the length of the concession lease from 46 years to 34 years. This mutual decision reduced risks associated with the project to both parties due to the end of lifecycle and replacement costs of the Rolling Stock (which have a useful product life of 30 years), and reduced the overall cost of the project (12 extra availability payments) by $2 billion.  At the time of the concession agreement being signed in July 2010, Macquarie Capital Group decided to sell its 90% equity stake in Denver Transit Partners to Denver Rail (Eagle) Holdings, Inc. (a unit of John Laing PLC which led the withdrawn Mile High Transit proposal) and Uberior Infrastructure Investments(No 4)USA LLC. According to Project Finance Magazine, the equity stake transfer was preplanned as part of the financing arrangement. 
Project Financing and Structure
|Source of Funding||Amount (in $millions)||Percent of Total|
|FTA New Starts Capital (Section 5309)||1030||46.8%|
|FHWA Flexible Funds (for CMAQ program)||62||2.8%|
|RTD Bond Proceeds||57||2.6%|
|RTD 0.4% Sales and Use Tax||114||5.2%|
|Contributions from the City of Aurora, City & County of Denver, Adams County, Jefferson County, City of Arvada, City of Wheat Ridge||40||1.8|
|Concessionaire Financing-Private Equity and Debt||488||22.2%|
|Total RTD original projected costs||2200||100%|
Availability Payment Structure
The Concession agreement is based off of both the project finance structure and a monthly service payment. The construction payments are paid out according to the financing structure which includes federal government funding, private funding, private activity bonds, and other loans. The construction payments are paid out in installments determined by two phases of the project and based on the progress achieved in the project. Construction Phase 1 is the East Line to Denver International Airport, which began in 2011 and is set to be completed in early 2015, and the Commuter Rail Maintenance Facility, which began in mid-2012 and is set to be completed first in early 2015. Construction Phase 2 is the Northwest Electrified Segment, the Gold Line to Arvada, both of which began in early 2012 and is set to be complete in late 2016. RTD retains some control over the financing. Construction Payments are based off of the Earned Value of Work, calculated by multiplying the percentage of work completed on a particular construction element according to the Original Baseline Schedule. All Construction Bills to RTD from the Concessionaire are audited by an Independent Engineer for the project. The Concessionaire must submit monthly reports to RTD according to the agreement detailing construction progress. 
Monthly service payments to the concessionaire will begin at the start of the Operations and Maintenance portion of the project once revenue raising lines are opened. These monthly payments from RTD will be based on a pre-agreed formula. RTD will determine and set all fares, collect the fares from the Concessionaire and bares the entirety of the risk associated with revenue raising ability of the project. The availability payments will be based on RTD's sales taxes, bonds, and local financing. 
The formula awards monthly availability payments adjusted based on system performance levels. The base availability payment per month ranges from slightly less than $3 million per month when the East Line firsts opens in 2016 to nearly $7 million per month at the end of the lease term, when all service expansions have been realized. This monthly rate however, can be reduced up to about 25% for poor service delivery (which takes into account on time performance, station closure time, maintenance delays, reduced capacity (from expected rates), station accessibility, elevator functions, cleanliness, trash removal, and graffiti cleanup, and passenger and employee safety). The payment can also be increased up through a 0.5% bonus for perfect delivery.  
Penta-P Pilot Project
In 2007 the Federal Transit Administration started a new funding program called the Public-Private Partnership Pilot Program (Penta-P). The goal of Penta-P was to study whether P3s, in comparison to conventional procurements, are beneficial in providing new fixed guideway projects that are seeking New Starts federal funding. Due to increasing costs associated with a raise in price for building materials and a drop in value of the sales tax due to economic recession, the RTD was now facing a $2 billion funding gap for their FasTracks program. The RTD saw an opportunity for the FasTracks program to benefit from Penta-P and came up with the Eagle project proposal as a candidate. Inclusion into the Penta-P program allowed RTD to enter into a streamlined review and funding process in order to deliver the project sooner. This streamlined process included allowing concurrent approval of the project into Preliminary Engineering and Final Design. In addition, the $1.03 billion from the FTA accounted for 46% of the total Eagle project funding and filled a significant gap in the FasTracks budget. Under Penta-P, the FTA put emphasis on the transfer of risk to the private partner tied with the life-cycle performance of the project, and the FTA would not provide full funding until the RTD and DTP entered into a binding public-private agreement that met their risk-transfer parameters. The FTA also provided a P3 advisor to the RTD in order to ensure the risk transfer was sufficiently protecting the RTD.
In order to transfer risk, RTD selected a DBFOM to allow the best partner to take on certain risks. In accordance with the FTA Penta-P program, the risks transferred to the private sector are the ones most associated with long-term life cycle costs. The 36-year operations and maintenance obligation gives the concessionaire strong motivation to design and build a facility that will provide the most long term value in order to maximize their return on investment.
|RTD Risks Retained||Risks Transferred to Concessionaire||Shared Risk|
|Design review timeliness||Concessionaire Design problems (delays, rejections)||Third Party design reviews and disputes|
|RTD Requested Changes||Construction delays||Non-discriminatory legislative changes|
|Delays in Site Access/Permitting||Cost Overruns||Force majeure events|
|Unforeseen Archaeological Findings/Delays||Additional land requirements|
|Environmental Findings/Impact Statement errors||Environmental compliance|
|Unidentified and dry Utilities||Geological obstacles|
|Legislative changes||Safety and Security|
|Ridership and Fare evasion||Concessionaire Specified permitting delays|
|Third Party Claims|
|Maintenance/Repair costs and delays during operations|
|delays associated with wet utilities|
|Condition of the system at the end of the lease|
|Failure to meet operating/performance standards|
|Agreements with railroads and compliance|
Colorado TABOR Conflict
Under Colorado law, taxpayers are protected under the Colorado Taxpayer Bill of Rights (TABOR) that restricts increases in revenues by Government entities. Under TABOR, state and local governments cannot raise tax rates without voter approval and cannot spend revenues collected under existing tax rates without voter approval if revenues grow faster than the rate of inflation and population growth. While voters approved a 2005 measure to issue a 5-year suspension against retaining excess revenue under TABOR, the restrictions on issuing multi-year fiscal obligations remained. This meant that as a Colorado government entity, RTD would be prevented from developing a new revenue source for availability payments to a potential concessionaire. At the start of the procurement process for the Eagle project, outside sources thought it was possible to try to go outside of TABOR to provide a legally enforceable commitment to the potential concessionaires, as it had been done several times before the financial recession. However, all three teams rejected this proposal and notified RTD the RFP would not be picked up if it was structured as such. As a result, RTD was forced to use 2004 voter approved debt requirements for the project. This meant the element of FFGA funding became more important as TABOR commitments do not apply to federal funds.
Current Project Status
Through September 2014, more than $1.04 billion (about 47% of the total project finance cost) has been spent in Denver. The Commuter Rail Maintenance facility received a temporary certificate of occupancy and is in its final construction phases ahead of schedule. The opening of the CRMF allows the delivery of rolling stock, and for rail cars and systems to begin their testing phases. The latest news on the East and Gold Lines is that DTP is in the process of laying track and electrical lines and the project is on schedule. Two major transit - interstate bridges have begun construction and are set for completion in 2015. The Concessionaire is keeping involved in the community, donating hundreds of hours of work time to community causes including food banks and extreme community makeover projects, as well as publicizing the project and advance notice of construction related street closures. 
- Should the RTD have offered compensation to failing bids?
- Should a bidding process still move forward with only two qualifying bidders?
- Did voter tax increase approval in 2004 signify full public support of the project?
- Can the positives of Denver's P3 Experience be replicated in other cities or for other types of projects?
- Should Denver utilize the same structure for larger and more long term transit expansions?
- RTD FasTracks Project Website: http://www.rtd-fastracks.com/main_1
- Concessionaire Website: http://www.denvertransitpartners.com/
- Fluor Project Profile: http://www.fluor.com/projects/Pages/ProjectInfoPage.aspx?PrjID=242
- Latest Project Newsletter: http://denvertransitpartners.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Project-Newsletter-Fall-2014.pdf
- Concession Agreement: http://www.rtd-fastracks.com/media/uploads/ep3/Concession_Agreement.pdf
- FTA Project Profile http://www.fta.dot.gov/documents/CO_Denver_Eagle_Commuter_Rail_complete_profile.pdf
- Procurement Project Lessons Learned (RTD): http://www.rtd-fastracks.com/media/uploads/ep3/Eagle_P3_Procurement_Lessons_Learned_Report.pdf
- 2011 Conference Presentation: P3 Success Story: http://www.nga.org/files/live/sites/NGA/files/pdf/1109PUBLICPRIVATELIEN.PDF
- Risk Management in the Development of a Penta-P Project http://www.apta.com/mc/rail/previous/2010/Papers/Risk-Management-in-the-Development-of-a-Penta-P-Project.pdf
- RTD FasTracks Plan http://www.rtd-fastracks.com/media/uploads/main/FasTracks_Plan.pdf
- RTD FasTracks Plan http://www.rtd-fastracks.com/media/uploads/main/FasTracks_Plan.pdf
- East Corridor Fact Sheet http://www.rtd-fastracks.com/media/uploads/ec/East_Rail_Fact_Sheet_2014.pdf
- Gold Line Fact Sheet http://www.rtd-fastracks.com/media/uploads/gl/GL_Fact_Sheet_2014.pdf
- Northwest Rail Line FAQ http://www.rtd-fastracks.com/nw_74
- RTD site on new railcars http://www.rtd-fastracks.com/ep3_84
- RTD Quarterly Newsletter Spring 2013 http://www.rtd-fastracks.com/ep3_64
- RTD Eagle P3 Lessons Learned http://www.rtd-fastracks.com/media/uploads/ep3/Eagle_P3_Procurement_Lessons_Learned_Report.pdf
- RTD Penta-P Fact Sheet http://www.rtd-fastracks.com/media/uploads/gl/Penta_P_fact_sheet_6-11-07.pdf
- Risk Management in the Development of a Penta-P Project http://www.apta.com/mc/rail/previous/2010/Papers/Risk-Management-in-the-Development-of-a-Penta-P-Project.pdf
- http://ncppp.org.previewdns.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/03/Carey.pdf (Slide 7)
- State Spending Limitations: TABOR and Ref C http://www.colorado.gov/cs/Satellite?blobcol=urldata&blobheader=application%2Fpdf&blobkey=id&blobtable=MungoBlobs&blobwhere=1251601829837&ssbinary=true
- RTD Lessons Learned Report http://www.rtd-fastracks.com/media/uploads/ep3/Eagle_P3_Procurement_Lessons_Learned_Report.pdf