AI Art Generation Handbook/AI Model Showdown

Note: If you have ideas for "high difficulty" prompts for me to test, kindly start a discussion here.

In this showdown format, we stick to the following format:

(i) Only one models per entity / author that are well supported by community (SD3 is out of the equations)

(ii) Each model have 4 chances to generate the images

(iii) Parameters for Local WebUI is left untouched (except for the numbers of images generated)

(iv) Scoring is as followed:


Legend	Score	Remark
	1 mark	Full compliance to the prompt
	0.5 mark	Partial compliance to prompt (Able to generate as per requested but it is not as exactly same as prompt descriptions/implied meanings)
	0 mark	No compliance to the prompt

Complex Prompt Adherences

Prompt 1:

An Indian actress wearing a yellow saree in a red room, in front of her there are 3 boxes : Box on the left consists of black yarn balls, box on the middle consists of puppies and box on the right consists of water bottles

Context:

(i) Testing AI Model of "concept bleeding" , i.e: Whether the red coloured wall will "bleed" into saree or otherwise / items in the box will spread to other areas

(ii) Testing AI Model of "relative positioning" , i.e: Able to identify the area of image for left , middle and right positions

(iii) Testing AI Model of "composition generation" , i,e: Able to generate multiple items at its specific arrangment


AI Model	Tally Score	Image 1	Image 2	Image 3	Image 4
SDXL	Img 1: 3.5 Img 2: 3.5 Img 3: 4 Img 4: 3 Total: 14 Score: 50%
SDXL		Indian actress Yellow saree Red room 3 boxes Black yarn balls Puppies Water bottles	Indian actress Yellow saree Red room 3 boxes Black yarn balls Puppies Water bottles	Indian actress Yellow saree Red room 3 boxes Black yarn balls Puppies Water bottles	Indian actress Yellow saree Red room 3 boxes Black yarn balls Puppies Water bottles
DALL-E 3	Img 1: 4 Img 2: 6 Img 3: 5.5 Img 4: 5 Total: 20.5 Score: 73%
DALL-E 3		Indian actress Yellow saree Red room 3 boxes Black yarn balls Puppies Water bottles	Indian actress Yellow saree Red room 3 boxes Black yarn balls Puppies Water bottles	Indian actress Yellow saree Red room 3 boxes Black yarn balls Puppies Water bottles	Indian actress Yellow saree Red room 3 boxes Black yarn balls Puppies Water bottles
Flux	Img 1: 5 Img 2: 7 Img 3: 7 Img 4: 7 Total: 20.5 Score: 92%
Flux	Img 1: 5 Img 2: 7 Img 3: 7 Img 4: 7 Total: 20.5 Score: 92%	Indian actress Yellow saree Red room 3 boxes Black yarn balls Puppies Water bottles	Indian actress Yellow saree Red room 3 boxes Black yarn balls Puppies Water bottles	Indian actress Yellow saree Red room 3 boxes Black yarn balls Puppies Water bottles	Indian actress Yellow saree Red room 3 boxes Black yarn balls Puppies Water bottles

Prompt 2:

An elderly Japanese tailor is working at his sewing table inside his own tailor shop in Nagasaki during the morning time. He is using a pair of scissor to cut a blue fabrics with polka dots design. Looking outside of the tailor shop, it is a busy and narrow street with peoples and a taxi cab.

Context:

(i) Testing AI Model of "perspective rendering", i.e Accurate perspective for different scenes viewed from inside, looking out.

(ii) Testing AI Model of "object interactions", i,e How the people handle the scissor and use it for cutting fabrics

AI Model	Tally Score	Image 1	Image 2	Image 3	Image 4
SDXL	Img 1: 4 Img 2: 3 Img 3: 3 Img 4: 4 Total: Score: 43%
SDXL	Img 1: 4 Img 2: 3 Img 3: 3 Img 4: 4 Total: Score: 43%	Elderly Japanese Tailor shop Sewing table Using a pair of scissor Blue fabrics with polka dots Busy and narrow street Peoples A taxi cab	Elderly Japanese Tailor shop Sewing table Using a pair of scissor Blue fabrics with polka dots Busy and narrow street Peoples A taxi cab	Elderly Japanese Tailor shop Sewing table Using a pair of scissor Blue fabrics with polka dots Busy and narrow street Peoples A taxi cab	Elderly Japanese Tailor shop Sewing table Using a pair of scissor Blue fabrics with polka dots Busy and narrow street Peoples A taxi cab
DALL-E 3	Img 1: 6.5 Img 2: 7 Img 3: 5 Img 4: 6 Total: Score: 76%
DALL-E 3	Img 1: 6.5 Img 2: 7 Img 3: 5 Img 4: 6 Total: Score: 76%	Elderly Japanese Tailor shop Sewing table Using a pair of scissor Blue fabrics with polka dots Busy and narrow street Peoples A taxi cab	Elderly Japanese Tailor shop Sewing table Using a pair of scissor Blue fabrics with polka dots Busy and narrow street Peoples A taxi cab	Elderly Japanese Tailor shop Sewing table Using a pair of scissor Blue fabrics with polka dots Busy and narrow street Peoples A taxi cab	Elderly Japanese Tailor shop Sewing table Using a pair of scissor Blue fabrics with polka dots Busy and narrow street Peoples A taxi cab
Flux	Img 1: 6.5 Img 2: 7.5 Img 3: 7.5 Img 4: 6.5 Total: Score: 89%
Flux		Elderly Japanese Tailor shop Sewing table Using a pair of scissor Blue fabrics with polka dots Busy and narrow street Peoples A taxi cab	Elderly Japanese Tailor shop Sewing table Using a pair of scissor Blue fabrics with polka dots Busy and narrow street Peoples A taxi cab	Elderly Japanese Tailor shop Sewing table Using a pair of scissor Blue fabrics with polka dots Busy and narrow street Peoples A taxi cab	Elderly Japanese Tailor shop Sewing table Using a pair of scissor Blue fabrics with polka dots Busy and narrow street Peoples A taxi cab

Prompt 3:

Advertisement photo of top down shot focusing on medicine 6-tablet blister pack , the medicine stored inside the pocket of blister pack looks like the logo from different types of social media (i.e Snapchat, Instagram, YouTube, WhatsApp, Facebook, Twitter )

Context:

(i) Testing AI Model of identify text and render all of the mentioned brand elements (i.e: In this case is the logo of famous social media platform)

(ii) Testing AI Model of the concept of counting (i.e: Able to generate 6 pockets for blister pack)

(iii) Testing AI Model of "simulation of transparent material concept" (i.e: Able to understand that the blister pack is usually transparent)

AI Model	Tally Score	Image 1	Image 2	Image 3	Image 4
SDXL	Img 1: 1.5 Img 2: 0.5 Img 3: 0.5 Img 4: 3 Total: 5.5 Score: 27.5%
SDXL		Top down shot 6-tablet Blister pack Stored inside pocket Social Media Logo	Top down shot 6-tablet Blister pack Stored inside pocket Social Media Logo	Top down shot 6-tablet Blister pack Stored inside pocket Social Media Logo	Top down shot 6-tablet Blister pack Stored inside pocket Social Media Logo
DALL-E 3	Img 1: 4 Img 2: 3.5 Img 3: 3.5 Img 4: 3.5 Total: 14.5 Score: 72.5%
DALL-E 3		Top down shot 6-tablet Blister pack Stored inside pocket Social Media Logo	Top down shot 6-tablet Blister pack Stored inside pocket Social Media Logo	Top down shot 6-tablet Blister pack Stored inside pocket Social Media Logo	Top down shot 6-tablet Blister pack Stored inside pocket Social Media Logo
Flux	Img 1: 4 Img 2: 4 Img 3: 4 Img 4: 2 Total: 14 Score: 70%
Flux	Img 1: 4 Img 2: 4 Img 3: 4 Img 4: 2 Total: 14 Score: 70%	Top down shot 6-tablet Blister pack Stored inside pocket Social Media Logo	Top down shot 6-tablet Blister pack Stored inside pocket Social Media Logo	Top down shot 6-tablet Blister pack Stored inside pocket Social Media Logo	Top down shot 6-tablet Blister pack Stored inside pocket Social Media Logo