Wikibooks talk:Requests for undeletion

From Wikibooks, the open-content textbooks collection

(Redirected from Wikibooks talk:Votes for undeletion)

Initial text adapted from [[en:Wikipedia:Votes for undeletion]]. --mav 11:09 2 Aug 2003 (UTC)

[edit] Archives

Some sections of this page disappeared. I think that I will try to create an archive, like the archives for WB:VFD. --Kernigh 06:54, 18 November 2005 (UTC)

[edit] SockPuppets

Do you guys count sockpuppets as valid votes - there seems to be some sockpuppetting in the VfD and votes on this page. For example Special:Contributions/Nyarlathotep's contributions number like 15 and 13 of those are on Votes for Deletion or Votes for Undeletion - I am guessing a sockpuppet for voting. Trödel 22:21, 29 November 2005 (UTC)

Or Special:Contributions/Oburo - 11 total edits

Or Special:Contributions/Dolive21 - 3 total edits

Trödel 22:33, 29 November 2005 (UTC)

I am not a Sock puppet, I mostly edit Wikipedia, so I did not have a Wikibooks account until I needed one to vote here. You can check my Wikipedia history under Dolive21. You could message me on Wikipedia and I will message you back comfirming that I am the same person. I will set up my user page on Wikipedia and it will say that i am the same person.Dolive21 10:58, 30 November 2005 (UTC)

I am not accusing you of being a sock. I just said that there looks like some sockpuppetting - and brought up the votes that have very few edits. Trödel 21:18, 30 November 2005 (UTC)

[edit] Original Vote

And the original vote wasn't much better - though claimed on this undeletion to be 11-7 in favor of keep - some votes cleary should not have been counted:

2 votes without attribution

Special:Contributions/81.42.156.202 - 2 edits

Special:Contributions/210.49.14.215 - 2 edits

Special:Contributions/AutisticPsycho - 2 edits

also the author of the legal nonsense Template:Illegalacts

Special:Contributions/Stephen_Tennant - 3 edits - voted keep

But if they were these delete votes should get the same treatment

Kolossos vote for delete was not counted Special:Contributions/80.185.19.96 - 1 edit

Neither was Special:Contributions/152.163.100.5 - 3 edits

Neither was the nominator Func from Wikipedia - who clearly indicated he was for delete.